SlyDuck
SlyDuck
Back to The Pond
Dev5 min read

Why Your SEO Audit Tool Is Lying to You

That 98/100 SEO score looks great. But it might be hiding real problems that affect your actual rankings.

James Wolf

James Wolf

Founder @ SlyDuck

December 27, 2025
SEO audit revealing hidden problems

The Vanity Score Problem

SEO audit tools love big numbers. "Your SEO score: 98/100!" But what does that number actually mean?

Usually: Your pages have title tags, alt text, meta descriptions. Basic technical checks pass.

What it doesn't tell you: Whether your content actually ranks, if pages are being crawled properly, what competitors are doing better.

What SEO Tools Miss

The Hard Stuff

  • Crawl depth and coverage
  • Content quality
  • Backlink profile
  • Real ranking performance

The Sample Size Problem

Most tools crawl 1% of your site. What's on the other 99%?

The Point-in-Time Problem

One-time audits are snapshots. SEO is ongoing.

What Actually Moves Rankings

  • Content that matches intent - Actually answers what users want
  • Backlinks - Still matter, still hard to get
  • Technical foundation - Speed, mobile, crawlability
  • User engagement - Click-through rate, time on page

A Better Approach

  • Know what you're ranking for (Search Console)
  • Audit continuously, not annually
  • Prioritize by impact
  • Track outcomes, not scores

---

SlyDuck's SEO scans catch technical issues and track changes over time. Start scanning.

SEO monitoring that matters

SlyDuck scans what actually impacts rankings—technical foundation, AI crawler access, and ongoing changes. Not vanity scores.

Get Real SEO Insights
James Wolf

James Wolf

Founder @ SlyDuck

Building SlyDuck: the growth dashboard for vibe coders. Builder, leader, Dad, creator.

Related Articles